After a little bit of sleuthing, I believe it's the Sandman (comics) fills (plus two other art pieces in different fandoms for the same recipient). All the details match up - and honestly, I don't think the art is so bad, I like the pencil colours and shading, and there are some nice stylistic choices made, even if there is certainly also room for improvement. I can only assume OP viewed them less charitably and more brattily because they were hoping for "more" (longer fics etc.) to dig their teeth into upon reveals, and then were disappointed by two very short fics and a lot of relatively "simple" art.
where do we stand on including minor (unrequested) crossovers in gift fics. it wouldn't be plot wise, more like a single character from the other canon appearing, and it's something my recip would almost 100% be aware of but I can't figure out if they've watched it/how they feel about it.
Very high-risk move IMO. Personally, even as someone who will read and enjoy full-on crossover fics, I dislike these kinds of minor crossover cameos and find it throws me out of the story to have some rando from a different canon show up when it's not part of the main premise of the story I signed up for. (There's also a lower but non-zero risk of having picked a crossover fandom/character that the recipient will be more specifically annoyed by, especially if it's a well-known fandom where they're likely to have formed at least some opinion if only, "Ugh, can everyone please stop talking about X?") OTOH, some people do actively enjoy and get a kick out of Easter egg-type references and cameo characters! But I wouldn't risk it in a gift fic without at least a clear indication they're into and up for crossovers in general.
You could probably run it on SquidgeWorld. Or as a wholly Dreamwidth-based exchange, though that would make the anonymous creator aspect much more of a headache for the mods.
small vent - for all those ppl who complain that fic writers cause more wank than fan artists and fan artists do nothing wrong ever, i have hardly ever since the days of kitty de sade seen any fic writer who claimed they wrote without knowing the canon. and i have seen plenty artists who have done this. i have received more than one art gift across a wide swathe of exchanges where artists have straight up admitted this. some have got away with it pretty well and a couple have drawn the characters way, way ooc or with the wrong hair color or clothing styles etc.
so nobody is innocent and wank-free in exchanges, not writers, not artists, not recips even. we all are wankers in the end.
I've gotten canon blind art before and frankly i don't care, all my fandoms are so assblastingly rare that it's the only art that exists and i'm grateful for the crumbs of garbage I receive
Yes, especially in smaller exchanges. I can't always do it that much in Yuletide because it's a big exchange with alot of rare fandoms I'm just not familiar enough, but I do intend to, if I have time over the holidays.
you better comment on your fic from me this year. last time i got you, nada. and this is the one fucking exchange i can't game or ask not to be matched. and no way i'm dropping this fandom as it's the one chance i get to write my blorbo of blorbos.
I think it's kind of funny you posted this on both memes, but I can't complain when it's something pleasant and innocuous. Congrats, coalie, it's nice when something has a steady stream of readers. Sorry it felt like it bombed at first, but that would tell me that people who click on it are really happy to have found it.
Do you mean you haven't written anything yet or that the gift you wrote shows up as 0 words on AO3 or that the gift that's waiting for you shows up as having 0 words?
if one person who is not the recip comments favorably on your fic, you have won yuletide as a writer. if you comment on your gift and at least one other non-gift fic, you have won yuletide as a reader
Someone anonymously but identifiably bitches about believing their writer used AI, and everybody wanks to the death over whether this entirely typical just-over-minimum blandly mediocre story is a perfectly normal Yuletide gift or very obviously AI-written, with bonus side wank over whether it qualifies as badfic or is a perfectly decent story people would have been happy to receive.
And/or we get at least one post-reveal pinch hit because someone definitely actually did use AI to make a placeholder that looked enough like a proper story to evade the mods' checks and then failed to replace it by reveals.
This pinch hit has been claimed, but you are welcome to post a treat!
Everyone in Yuletide can currently receive treats except: Aleesha_Amber does not accept gifts. theblakery does not accept gifts. Arsenic does not accept gifts. kastlekitty does not accept gifts. baptisia does not accept gifts. crabwize does not accept gifts.
Star Trek Holidays due Dec 14startrekholidays https://startrekholidays.dreamwidth.org/2024/12/05/
Due: December 14 at 11 PM AST
Gifts must be one of: -a fic of at least 1,000 words long; -a podfic of a fic of at least 1,000 words in length OR 500 words of a fic created for this round; -a piece of art not on lined paper that has clean linework; -a fanvid of at least 1:00 in length.
Details: PH 3 - art, fic - Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
PH 4 - fic - Star Trek: Deep Space Nine x6, Little Achievements - Alexander Siddig & Andrew Robinson DS9 fanfic (Video), The Lives of Dax - Marco Palmieri (editor)
Highlander Holiday Shortcuts due Dec 15hlh_shortcuts
Min: 500 words. Deadline: December 15th, midnight CST.
That is: please get in touch with the mods if you could write for some or several of these characters and could write a 500-word fic by this deadline.
Yuletide due early Dec 18yuletide_pinch_hits https://yuletide-pinch-hits.dreamwidth.org/2024/12/08/
Due: 9am UTC December 18. MInimum: 1,000 words featuring all requested characters.
PH #100: Interview with the Vampire (TV 2022) RPF, Killjoys (TV), Constantine (TV), L.A. By Night (Web Series
Consent Issues due 5 Januaryconsent_issues_exchange https://consent-issues-exchange.dreamwidth.org/2024/11/28/
Due: 5 January, 10pm EST. Minimums: Fic: 1k with beginning/middle/end. Art: a finished piece of clean line art on unlined paper, or digital equivalent.
PH 2 - fic - バチカン奇跡調査官 | Vatican Kiseki Chousakan | Vatican Miracle Examiner (Anime), Murdle Series - G. T. Karber, 大逆転裁判 | Dai Gyakuten Saiban | The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles (Video Games)
PH 10 - art, fic - Майор Гром | Major Grom (Comics), 名探偵コナン | Detective Conan | Case Closed
PH 13 - art, fic [varies by request] - 幽☆遊☆白書 | YuYu Hakusho: Ghost Files (Anime & Manga), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, Yuri!!! on Ice (Anime), Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series), Gravity Falls, Outlast (Video Games)
PH 22 - art, fic - Durarara!!, 組長娘と世話係 | Kumichou Musume to Sewagakari | The Yakuza's Guide to Babysitting (Anime), 龍が如く | Ryuu ga Gotoku | Yakuza (Video Games) Link Reply Thread from start Parent
Wintertime Woes due 11 Januarywintertime_woes_exchange https://wintertime-woes-exchange.dreamwidth.org/2024/11/26/
Due: January 11, 11:59pm UTC. MInimums: 500 words or a sketch on unlined paper.
PH 1 - fic - Degrassi the Next Generation, Girl Meets World (TV 2014), Red Band Society (US TV), Short Term 12 (2013), Solitaire - Alice Oseman, Turtles All the Way Down (2024)
PH 2 - art, fic [varies by request] - The Walking Dead (TV), Bunny - Mona Awad, Yellowjackets (TV), Higurashi no Naku Koro ni | Higurashi When They Cry, The Last of Us (TV), Crossover Fandom, The Witcher (TV) x3, The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (TV 2022)
PH 4 - fic - Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling x4, Chronicles of Narnia - C. S. Lewis, Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) - All Media Types, Star Wars Prequel Trilogy, Star Trek: Voyager, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
FFFX due 18 Januaryfffx | Five Figure Fanwork Exchange, a multifandom exchange for longfic/comics https://fffx.dreamwidth.org/2024/11/29/
Due Saturday 18 January, 11:59pm EST. Minimum requirements: An art gift must be a completed comic at least 10 pages or 40 panels long; a fic gift must be a story at least 10,000 words long. You can also fulfil a pinch hit by giving two complete half-length works, if your recipient has opted into that for the fandom(s) you are creating in. Any work must be for a fandom your recipient has requested and one character/relationship/worldbuilding tag requested in that fandom, and must avoid their DNWs.
Pinch hit #1 - art, fic [varies by request] - Chants of Sennaar (Video Game), 不機嫌なモノノケ庵 | Fukigen na Mononokean | The Morose Mononokean, Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind, 光の伝説 | Hikari no Densetsu | Legend of Light (Anime), Onmyouji | The Yin-Yang Master (Movies 2001 2003) ) Canon promo exists for: The Morose Mononokean
Pinch hit #35 - fic - The Bear (TV 2022), Final Fantasy XIV, Final Fantasy XV, Naruto (Anime & Manga)
Pinch hit #36 - art, fic - Rivers of London - Ben Aaronovitch, Star Wars Legends - All Media Types, Enola Holmes (Movies), Crossover Fandom [various], Babylon 5 (TV 1993), Star Trek: The Next Generation, Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Star Trek: The Original Series, Stargate SG-1
Pinch hit #42 - fic - Grey's Anatomy, House M.D., Mr. & Mrs. Smith (TV 2024), Murder Most Unladylike Series - Robin Stevens, NCIS: Los Angeles, Ocean's Eleven Trilogy (Movies), SEAL Team (TV), Why Didn't They Ask Evans? (TV 2022)
Pinch hit #46 - fic - Captain America (Movies), Crossover Fandom [DCEU/MCU], Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), Angel: the Series, Game of Thrones (TV), House of the Dragon (TV), Chaos Walking - Patrick Ness, Pretty Woman (1990), Stranger Things (TV 2016) ) Canon promo post exists for: House of the Dragon
Pinch hit #55 - fic - Secret Circle - L. J. Smith, Jurassic Park Original Trilogy (Movies), Good Omens (TV), Bones (TV), The West Wing, Stargate Atlantis, Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV), Doctor Who (2005), Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, A Stitch in Time - Andrew J. Robinson (Book)
Pinch hit #56 - art, fic [varies by request] - Drop-Out (Webcomic), Echo (Visual Novel 2019), Lost (TV 2004), NEEDY GIRL OVERDOSE (Visual Novel), Serious Weakness - Porpentine Charity Heartscape, 咎狗の血 | Togainu no Chi (Visual Novel), 素晴らしき日々 〜不連続存在〜 | Wonderful Everyday ~Diskontinuierliches Dasein~ (Video Game)
Pinch hit #57 - art, fic - Hell Followed With Us - Andrew Joseph White, The Mysterious Benedict Society - Trenton Lee Stewart, Yotsuba to! | Yotsuba&!, The Super Mario Bros. Movie (2023), Doctor Who (2005)
Pinch hit #58 - art, fic - One Piece (Anime & Manga), ジョジョの奇妙な冒険 | JoJo no Kimyou na Bouken | JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series)
Pinch hit #60 - art, fic - Discworld - Terry Pratchett, Trese (Cartoon), Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves (2023), Orphan Black (TV), Teen Wolf (TV), Thor (Movies)
Pinch hit #62 - fic - Leverage (US TV 2008), Star Wars Prequel Trilogy, Star Wars Original Trilogy, White Collar (TV 2009), DCU (Comics), Star Trek: The Original Series, Star Trek: Alternate Original Series (Movies)
Holly Poly due 26 Januaryholly_poly https://holly-poly.dreamwidth.org/2024/12/06/ https://groups.google.com/g/holly-poly-pinchhits
Due: 26 January, 11:00am UTC. Minimums: please see rules: https://archiveofourown.org/collections/holly_poly_2024/profile#rules
#3: The Witcher (TV), One Piece (Live Action TV 2023), crossover - Fandom, Lost (TV 2004)
#5: Havenfall is for Lovers (Visual Novel), The Elementalists (Visual Novel), Fate/Grand Order
#6: Animator vs. Animation (Short Films - Becker), Video Blogging RPF, Battle For Dream Island (Web Series), ONE - Cheesy Hfj (Web Series), Inanimate Insanity (Web Series)
Page 10 of 14