CoalCeption

[coalcube]

The wank is coming from inside the house.

NYR due before you sign up for 2019 Yuletide.
Nominations: 2 October (time tba) to 11 October, 9am UTC
Sign-ups: 27 October (time tba) to 4 November, 9am UTC
Prompts revealed and Madness opens: Approx 9 November
Default deadline: 11 December, 9am UTC
Assignment deadline: 18 December, 9am UTC
Main Collection Reveals: 25 December (time tba)

Yuletide Discord for Hippos. Google Group for PHs.

yuletide | yuletide_admin 

2019 Tagset | 2019 Collection | Sign Ups
2019 App | Letter Post (LJ) 
YuleSwaps | Crueltide | Yuleporn 

Flat / Recent | Top-Level (Last)

 

Comments

Re: Best/Worst Evidence Posts

[(Anonymous)]

https://yuletide-admin.dreamwidth.org/64432.html?thread=999856#cmt999856

Re: Best/Worst Evidence Posts

[(Anonymous)]

"series 3 has a group of Stand Users traveling the world to defeat the Evil Bad Guy. Series 5 has a group of Mafia members/Stand Users who decide to turn against their Boss who is spreading drug use throughout Italy. These couldn't be more different."

"Different series have different overarching plots" is a bit weaksauce, agreed.

Re: Best/Worst Evidence Posts

[(Anonymous)]

The style overall changes between parts as well - it's not just the main plot type, there are other differences between, say, a procedural and a horror movie. That said, I still wouldn't have even considered arguing for parts 1-6, though looking as some other "borderline cases" that were okayed in the past I can see why someone would try. Though you'd think they would try to sound more convincing.

Parts 7 and 8 are genuine only-few-things-in-common AUs. Think Marvel 1602 to 616, but even fewer shared names/concepts/other elements. Though I think the person who nominated 7 alone (Steel Ball Run) could have made a better argument too. That said, a lot of people tend to throw several prominent characters into the all-parts crossovers so I don't know how the numbers pan out.