Coal All The Way

[coalcube]

It's coal-bo time.

 Coal Friending Meme


Yuleporn | Make the Yuletide Gay / TNB+ | Femslash Festivus 
YuleBuilding | Two for One | Crueltide | Misses Clause
YuleSwaps | IF | Wrapping Paper 

Yuletide Discord for Hippos. Google Group for PHs. F_F wiki for history.

yuletide | yuletide_admin | Writing Post
2019 Collection | 2019 Madness
2019 App | Letter Post (LJ) 
 

Flat / Recent | Top-Level (Last) | Search

Comments

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

DA

That's not necessarily helpful when it's a placeholder being replaced with a different fic.

My gift went from 1.5k (placeholder) after reveals to 1k (actual fic, unifinished) shortly after and then slowly back to 1.6k (actual finished fic) over the next couple of hours. Just comparing the word count would make me assume that the author did only minor revisions.

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

100 words is a lot though? Fixing typos and tense shifts are minor and that would usually add maybe 30 words. 100 would be some tangible edits.

If you reread a fic that made you feel crazy and then saw there was a 100 word difference, wouldn’t you assume whatever you don’t remember is new?

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

AYRT

Honestly, not really? My memory is terrible. I very likely wouldn't even notice a 100 word difference in a fic. My point is: in this case, the 100 word difference on paper (which to me is minor, tbh; I can see how you could get there just by fixing awkward turns of phrase and maybe adding a sentence) actually amounted to a much larger difference because the whole fic was replaced.

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

Sure, but since you understand that someone could literally do a 1-1 switch with an entirely different fic that has the exact same word count, it seems weirdly self-defeatist to still question yourself if you feel something is off. I’m sorry your memory sucks, but fanfiction is low stakes. You are allowed to blindly assume your memory is right and then author completely revamped the fic if doing so makes you feel more sound/comfortable.

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

the* author

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

AYRT

I'm just saying that the word count is a bad indicator for change, that's all.

Not to mention it requires that you kept the gift notification. Which someone who comes back to reread after a while would likely not have.

Like the coalie upthread said, if you do make significant changes on your fic for some reason, a short line or two in the author's notes is helpful. Not just to let the recipient know they didn't imagine things, but also because a note would potentially make the recipient more inclined to assume good faith than the author stealthily working on their fic after the deadline and acting like it's not happening. A 'oh damn, I uploaded the wrong word document, sorry!' may or may not be actually true, but I'll probably believe you had a complete fic all along.

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

A 'oh damn, I uploaded the wrong word document, sorry!' may or may not be actually true, but I'll probably believe you had a complete fic all along.

+1

I'll be much more forgiving of this than if a new story or major revisions show up. I'd probably go to the mods with that, not asking for a pinch hit but because I'm annoyed that it intentionally wasn't a complete story at the last possible due date.

Re: post-reveals (minor) edits

[(Anonymous)]

I feel like whether 100 words is "a lot" depends on how long the fic is. Like if you go from 1000 to 1100, that's a 10% increase, and definitely a lot. If you go from 25,000 to 25,100, then that's a, umm, much smaller percentage increase and doesn't matter so much.