I once got a deeply charming and awkwardly written baby’s first smutfic that didn’t really understand how tribbing worked and had literotica sex moan dialog but it was the fandom and pairing of my heart and they really put their all into it, though clumsily. I love it for the author’s earnestness. Also it’s kind of funny.

I also once got literal kittyfic, which was not charming at all.